What if someone you loved was murdered and you were accused and put on death row? This is the story of Greg Wilhoit, whose wife was murdered and he was left to take care of his two daughters alone. Almost a year later, Wiilhoit was charged with the murder and arrested due to the reports from two dental "experts" (one had only been out of dental school for a year) who claimed that a bite mark on Wilhoit's wife matched his teeth. Wilhoit said the judge told him he was "going to die by lethal injection. But if that fails, we'll kill you by electrocution. If the power goes out, we'll hang you. If the rope breaks, we'll take you out back and shoot you." In the end, Wilhoit was lucky enough to be saved from being murdered when they realized he was not guilty. He went on to struggle with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder for the rest of his life.
Stories like Wilhoit's are not uncommon. Just type: "sad stories of the death penalty" into google and hundreds of articles appear. Many include innocent people being killed. But false-accusations are not the only problem of the death penalty. Haven't we been taught since we were children that "two wrongs don't make a right?" Within Vice and Virtue, John Stuart Mill supports this theory by stating, actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness." He brings up an interesting point in saying that we shouldn't commit actions that are the opposite of happiness- for example, killing someone. Lastly, why would we kill horrible criminals when that's what most of them want since they would otherwise be in jail for the rest of their lives?
My belief that the death penalty is not justified most likely stemmed from my high beliefs in the harm/care pillar of the five pillars. This is the most important pillar to me and the death penalty breaks its values. Within the 4 C's character and culture stand out to me because for culture, my parents raised me to believe that if someone does something wrong, you should not reciprocate their wrongness. If my sister hit me, I was taught that if I hit her back, I was just as wrong as she was. The character aspect of the 4 C's also applies because one of my personality traits is acceptance (accepting others to have another chance- this does not necessarily mean to be let out out of jail, but allowing them to attempt at a second chance in adjusting who they are as a person before they die).
Pro-death penalty article:
http://www.biblebelievers.com/jmelton/punish.html
This article provides the reasoning that the death penalty is good because: it honors God, it is a deterrent to crime, and it is good for the environment (to flush out the bad souls).
Against death penalty article:
http://www.antideathpenalty.org/reasons.html
This article provides the reasoning that the death penalty is bad because: executions cot more than a life in prison, innocents might be wrongly executed, it is not a deterrent; crime rates have not decreased, life in prison also guarantees no future crimes, killing is wrong, violates international human rights laws, promotes killing as an okay solution to a difficult problem, and death sentences are handed down arbitrarily and not in a fair manner.
Why do humans have the instinct to seek revenge?
No comments:
Post a Comment