Monday, September 29, 2014

Men Paying For Meals Creates a Power Imbalance in Terms of Gender

Two weekends ago, I went to Homecoming with a friend of mine as a date. A large group of us ate at someone’s house, and he charged us twenty dollars each for the meal that he served. In previous years, there was no question as to who would pay for my meal; my date, as it was a tradition for the man to pay. However, when it came time to pay I glanced over at him and saw he was holding twenty dollars, only enough for himself. At first, I thought: how rude. He was supposed to pay for my meal since I was his date, and he was the boy. But then I thought about this sexist tradition as a whole. Why are men obligated to always pay for women?
This tradition dates way back to the 1920’s when going out on dates became popular due to the fact that women did not have high-paying jobs or jobs at all, so the men would pay for their meal. But mostly, it was because the men expected the women to return the favor after the date. Is this feeling of control that men seek really what this folkway is about? In today’s society, mostly this tradition is an act of common courtesy, however, a young woman named Kristina Hoock admits to NBC News: “I feel uncomfortable if a guy pays for everything. I feel like the balance of power has shifted in his direction. I want to at least provide for myself. This is my date too.” She was in a relationship once where the guy never let her help out with money. He would buy her over eight hundred dollars of clothing on a single trip to the mall, and even though he was expressing his care for her, these purchases made her feel more obligated to stay in a relationship with him. 
This power imbalance that Hoock mentioned and experienced is brought up on a more extreme scale by Philip Hallie in his article, “From Cruelty to Goodness.” He states, “The opposite of cruelty lay in a situation where there is no imbalance of power.” Therefore, it is cruel that men pay for the date when they either: want something in return, or the woman is perfectly capable to pay but strips the man of his earnings on an expensive steak dinner. How is this cruel if men are just trying to be nice? Hallie explains, “kindness could be the ultimate cruelty, especially when it was given within that unbalanced power relationship.” He means that this act of kindness of paying for a meal makes women feel as though they have to provide something in return. The image that men have more money than women could be dangerous, as seen in Hallie’s example of slavery: the reason why slavery occurred was because whites had “economic and political ascendancy” over blacks.

In the 1920’s, women usually did not have enough money to pay for themselves, however, many are successful today. While women still only earn seventy-seven cents to every dollar men make, a sufficient amount make more than the men they date. After all, according to NBC News, “Only sixteen percent of men say they expect something when they provide for the woman.” In other words, most of the responsibility for this power imbalance lies in the hands of women. Janet Lever, a sociologist at California State University, gives the message, “It’s a totally different world, and it’s an expensive world. [A woman] can’t go around being a little princess on the pedestal.” NBC News gives the statistics that 66% of men want women to chip in after a few dates and 26% of women are bothered when men don't let them pay. If most men want women to pay sometimes and over one-fourth of women are upset they aren't allowed to pay due to cultural norms, then why is this tradition still set in stone? It causes men to have more authority and women to not reciprocate economically- it is unfair to both genders. Despite the fact that it is a tradition, the expectation for men to pay needs to decrease, just as the expectation for women to pay needs to increase, in order to create a balanced power relationship within our society. 

Tuesday, September 9, 2014

                               Do Groups vs. Individuality Affect the Moral Brain Triggers?

     When questioned about a moral moment in my dad's life, he stood pacing in the kitchen.
     "Hmmm," he said, " I have a personal one and an international one." The fact that his brain led him to these two categories of morale immediately reminded me of Pinker's "Moral Instinct," when he explains the deeper complexities of the brain when thinking of what is morally "right." The two stories were different, yet similar especially in how they compare to what we've been learning in class.
       The international "moral moment" my dad described was possibly one of the most frightening moments in American history- 9/11. I told him about Haidt's five moral foundations and asked him which he thought would fall under this event, and he answered, "harm and the authority of the Muslims leading the attack. Actually, I would throw all of [the five categories] in there. I mean, it was crazy." But then again, weren't the Muslims doing what they thought was "morally right" in killing all of these innocent people in order to serve Allah? My dad and I talked about it and came to the conclusion that it is not right due to the fact that their loyal and pure reasoning violated all three of the other five categories immensely. This led me to reflect on our discussion in class when most of our class concluded that it was okay for the Nazis to kill all those people because it was morally right to serve their country, and I changed my mind to believing it is still not okay. My dad agrees, saying, "just because a figure of authority is telling you something and it seems right because you're in a large group of people doesn't mean you shouldn't take pause and think about it because if that authority is doing things that jeopardize some other morals it is wrong." However, this theory would violate the authority category, making things even more complex.
      My dad then went on to tell the more personal story; he was helping film/broadcast a high school football game with his friend Shoe in Vermont and a not-so-attractive teenage girl fell down the stairs. She was obviously hurt and nobody even flinched to help her. Shoe dropped all of his equipment and stopped to asked her if she needed any help and they both helped walk her to where there was a payphone. He reflected on how it wasn't even his first instinct to help her because he was preoccupied with filming the game and also how he gained a ton of respect for his friend that day and it lengthened his own morals. It also unfortunately forced him to ask himself if the reason people didn't help her was because she was unattractive. His quote: "There's a lot of psychology with crowds- if a person falls in New York City when there are a shit ton of people no one's bound to help another person whereas if you're the only person on the street then it doesn't even occur to you not to help the other person," reminded me of Pinker's example of the train and different scenarios when having to choose between saving one vs. five people. Why does this group vs. individual psychology have such an impact on our emotions/brains?
                                                                                                                                                                 

http://mrkaiser208.files.wordpress.com/2010/05/group.jpg



Pinker, Steven, "Moral Instinct," 2/10/08, 9/9/14